B.C. man beat a woman with a bat in her bedroom. A judge praised his remorse and reduced his sentence

B.C. man beat a woman with a bat in her bedroom. A judge praised his remorse and reduced his sentence

A B.C. man who broke into a woman’s home and beat her with a baseball bat while her children hid nearby was awarded a reduced sentence last week because the judge was convinced the 25-year-old is “not now the person he was when he viciously and irrationally attacked” his victim.

Craig Brentton Durando was granted a conditional sentence of two years less a day for assault with a weapon, robbery and breaking and entering — offences to which he pleaded guilty last October — allowing him to serve his time in a provincial correctional facility.

Share

Outrage as three teenage rapists avoid jail and are fined just £26 each: ‘It is less than a parking fine’

Teenage rapists are being let off with £26 fines after being convicted of attacking girls as young as 14.

Rape campaigners reacted with fury yesterday as it emerged that in at least three cases teenage perpetrators have been spared jail and handed rehabilitation orders with financial penalties that are ‘less than a parking ticket’.

Harriet Wistrich, head of the Centre for Women’s Justice, has called for a review to establish whether lenient sentences are becoming the norm.

Share

How can gang-raping schoolgirls at knifepoint not lead to a prison sentence?

How can gang-raping schoolgirls at knifepoint not lead to a prison sentence?

‘I think of you as very young’, said Judge Nicholas Rowland to a trio of Traveller teenage boys in Southampton Crown Court yesterday. ‘None of you have been in any big trouble before… You have all done very well with the restrictions put in place throughout the trial.’ He assured the minors – the youngest of whom was just 14 years old – that ‘none of you need to go to prison today’.

Share

Canadian judge gives Indian trucker only 2.5 years behind bars for killing Olympic figure skater while plowing through cars in construction zone

Canadian judge gives Indian trucker only 2.5 years behind bars for killing Olympic figure skater while plowing through cars in construction zone

Man, am I the only one getting sick and tired of hearing this type of story every day?

An Indian trucker who had been driving for 16 hours straight when he smashed through a construction zone and killed an Olympic figure skater and mom was given a 2.5 year sentence after pleading guilty in an Ontario court.

h/t patthedog

Share

Judge gives lenient sentence so trucker can dodge deportation after fatal Ontario crash

Judge gives lenient sentence so trucker can dodge deportation after fatal Ontario crash

A Thunder Bay judge has issued an absolute discharge so an Indian trucker who pleaded guilty to dangerous driving in a fatal crash can avoid deportation.

The Ontario Superior Court of Justice heard Ajitpal Singh was driving too close behind another truck that lost control and jackknifed on Highway 102 in December 2021, killing the driver of a truck heading in the opposite direction, and severely injuring a passenger.

Share

Mohamad Lilo beats murder charge, takes plea deal in Elnaz Hajtamiri kidnapping conspiracy

Mohamad Lilo beats murder charge, takes plea deal in Elnaz Hajtamiri kidnapping conspiracy

The Montreal-area man accused of first-degree murder following the January 2022 abduction of his former girlfriend from a home in Wasaga Beach, Ont., has accepted a plea deal.

Mohamad Lilo, 38, pleaded guilty to conspiracy to kidnap Elnaz Hajtamiri, in exchange for murder charges against him being dropped by the Crown and a joint proposal of a four-year sentence, which was accepted by Justice Michelle Furst.

Share

What counts as the woods? Judge axes Nova Scotia’s ban that defied ‘commonsense definitions’

What counts as the woods? Judge axes Nova Scotia’s ban that defied ‘commonsense definitions’

As wildfires raged across Nova Scotia last summer, the Canadian province made a simple plea to residents: stay away from the woods.

As the situation deteriorated, authorities turned the request into a prohibition: anyone caught hiking under the shade of the forest canopy faced a C$25,000 fine – a figure more than half the average worker’s yearly salary.

But exactly the emergency rules considered to be “the woods” was a challenge better suited to a philosopher than a confused hiker in a parking lot. Rock barrens, scrubland or marshes were all considered “woods”. So too was forest – but the presence of actual trees wasn’t necessary, just evidence they had once been there. Residents could still travel as long as it wasn’t “any great distance” through the woods.

Share

Murder charges will be dropped against Kenneth Law; he will plead guilty to aiding suicide instead, lawyer says

Murder charges will be dropped against Kenneth Law; he will plead guilty to aiding suicide instead, lawyer says

An Ontario man accused of selling a toxic substance online to vulnerable people who used it to end their lives will no longer face murder charges and will instead plead guilty to 14 counts of aiding suicide, his lawyer says.

Kenneth Law, 60, has been publicly accused of running websites that shipped more than a thousand packages of deadly substances and other materials used for self-harm to more than 40 countries. Many of Law’s customers were young people who allegedly used the substance to end their lives; the Star has spoken to parents in Canada, the U.S., Australia, New Zealand and the United Kingdom.


I bet we find out this guy is the diversity added to Ontario’s MAID review board?

Share

There’s no reason for courts to be setting Canadian immigration policy

There’s no reason for courts to be setting Canadian immigration policy

In a recent ruling, Court of Quebec judge Antoine Piché tore a strip off Crown prosecutors who appear before him for discounting sentences based on offenders’ immigration status, to avoid non-citizens being flagged for deportation — which is supposed to happen after a criminal sentence of six months or more is handed down.

I was most intrigued by Piché’s annoyance at the widespread insistence that this doesn’t happen. This is one of those Canadian phenomena that clearly exists — National Post has reported many such cases, many of which wouldn’t be known to the public otherwise — but that we’re supposed to pretend does not.

Share

Judge accuses Montreal prosecutors of suggesting lower sentences to prevent deportations

Judge accuses Montreal prosecutors of suggesting lower sentences to prevent deportations

A Quebec judge has condemned what he considers to be a two-tier justice system in Montreal after alleging that prosecutors often recommend more lenient sentences for criminals at risk of being deported.

The Quebec Crown prosecution office, however, is denying the judge’s accusations, saying no directive to such effect has been issued.

In a decision handed down on Wednesday, Quebec Court Justice Antoine Piché slammed prosecutors in Montreal for “regularly” suggesting that offenders receive less severe sentences, including an acquittal in some cases, so as not to jeopardize their immigration status.


Lawyers are merde. You’re right they do hate us.

Share

MANDEL: Pearson gold heist mastermind sentenced to just four years in jail

MANDEL: Pearson gold heist mastermind sentenced to just four years in jail

One of the key masterminds behind Canada’s largest gold heist — the brazen theft of $22.5 million in gold and cash from Toronto’s Pearson airport three years ago — has been sentenced to just four years behind bars.

Less credit for pre-sentence custody, the relieved Arsalan Chaudhary has just 42 months left to serve. But that’s not the entirety of his sentence: Ontario Court Justice Shannon McPherson ordered the 44-year-old to pay back $22 million to Brinks — a restitution order that will stand for 40 years.

Share

Canada’s Supreme Court has given youths sentenced as adults a ‘get-out-of-prison-early’ pass

Canada’s Supreme Court has given youths sentenced as adults a ‘get-out-of-prison-early’ pass

Last summer, Canada’s Supreme Court sent an inadvertent message to all young offenders in Canada: you will almost certainly never be sentenced as an adult.

Even before the Court released its judgement in R v. I.M., which changed the standard for which youth can be sentenced as adults, it was already true that young offenders would be treated more leniently in sentencing than adults. For a second-degree murder conviction, for example, which comes with a life sentence without parole for 10 to 25 years for an adult, a youth offender would be eligible for parole after five to seven years, depending on his or her age at the time of the offence, even if the youth was sentenced as an adult. That discrepancy is reasonably justified if we, as a society, accept that young people are of “diminished moral blameworthiness” for their actions compared to fully developed adults.

Share